ldy26098
/
BMAD-METHOD
mirror of https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD.git
1
0
Fork 0
Code Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
BMAD-METHOD/learn-wds-audit.md

3.4 KiB
Raw Blame History

Learn-WDS Course Structure Audit

Date: 2025-12-31
Status: Issues Identified - Needs Major Cleanup

Critical Issues Found

1. Module Numbering Conflicts

Module 04 appears TWICE:

  • module-04-product-brief/ (Phase 1: Project Brief)
  • Listed in overview as "Module 04: Identify Target Groups" (Phase 2)

Actual folders don't match overview listing:

  • Overview lists: Module 04-12
  • Folders show: module-01 through module-12, but with gaps and conflicts

2. Massive Duplication in Module 02

Module 02 has multiple duplicate lesson folders:

  • lesson-01-git-setup/
  • lesson-01-github-and-ide-setup/
  • lesson-01-setting-up-github/
  • lesson-02-git-configuration/
  • lesson-02-ide-installation/
  • lesson-02-install-ide/
  • lesson-03-git-cloning/
  • lesson-03-git-setup/
  • lesson-04-clone-and-wds/
  • lesson-04-wds-initialization/
  • lesson-05-initiate-mimir/

Looks like: Multiple attempts at organizing the same content, never cleaned up.

3. Inconsistent Folder Structure

Some modules have structure:

  • module-01: Has lessons + overview ✅
  • module-02: Has lessons + overview (but duplicated) ⚠️
  • module-03: Has lessons + overview ✅

Some modules only have tutorial:

  • module-04: Only tutorial-04.md
  • module-05: Only tutorial-04.md (wrong number!)
  • module-06: Only tutorial-06.md
  • module-08: Only tutorial-08.md
  • module-09: Only tutorial-09.md
  • module-10: Only tutorial-10.md
  • module-12: Only tutorial-12.md

Missing modules:

  • module-07: Doesn't exist
  • module-11: Doesn't exist

4. Missing VTC Integration

Course doesn't mention:

  • VTC creation in Module 04 (Product Brief)
  • VTC workshop in scenario initialization

Recommended Actions

Immediate (Critical):

  1. Fix Module Numbering

    • Rename folders to match correct phase structure
    • Update course overview to match actual folders

  2. Clean Module 02 Duplicates

    • Identify canonical lesson structure
    • Delete duplicate folders
    • Keep only one clear path

  3. Complete Missing Modules

    • Add lesson content to modules 04-12
    • Or mark as "Tutorial Only" if intended

  4. Add VTC to Course

    • Module 04: Add VTC creation step
    • Module on Scenario Init: Add VTC workshop

Longer Term (Enhancement):

  1. Standardize Module Structure

    • Every module should have:
      • module-XX-overview.md
      • lesson-XX-YYY.md files
      • tutorial-XX.md (if practical module)

  2. Cross-Reference Verification

    • Check all links in course overview
    • Verify tutorial paths
    • Update any broken references

Impact Assessment

Current State:

  • ❌ Course structure is confusing
  • ❌ Major duplications waste space
  • ❌ Module numbering doesn't match content
  • ❌ Missing key content (VTC)
  • ⚠️ Some modules incomplete

Estimated Cleanup Time: 4-6 hours

Priority: HIGH - Course is user-facing educational content

Decision Point

Options:

A) Full Cleanup Now

  • Pros: Course becomes usable, consistent
  • Cons: Takes 4-6 hours
  • When: If course is active/being used

B) Document & Defer

  • Pros: Move forward with other audits
  • Cons: Course remains messy
  • When: If course is not yet active

C) Partial Cleanup

  • Fix: Module numbering, obvious duplicates
  • Defer: Content completion
  • Time: 1-2 hours

Recommendation: Option C (Partial Cleanup) - fix structural issues, defer content completion.

Audit complete - awaiting decision