7.7 KiB

Raw Blame History

PR #826 Validation Findings

Date: 2025-01-28
Branch: pr-826-review
File: high-level-product-plan.md

Summary

The file from PR #826 has been successfully applied to the pr-826-review branch and validated. While the content is technically sound, there are quality issues and convention violations that need to be addressed before merging.

Validation Results

✅ Syntax Validation

Markdown Structure: VALID
- All headings properly formatted (#, ##, ###)
- Lists use consistent formatting (numbered and bulleted)
- No broken syntax detected

❌ Code Style Issues

Prettier Check: FAILED
- Status: [warn] high-level-product-plan.md
- Issue: 148 trailing whitespace errors
- Impact: Violates project code style standards
- Fix: npx prettier --write "high-level-product-plan.md"

❌ File Placement

Current Location: Repository root (/high-level-product-plan.md)
Convention Violation: Root directory restricted to:
- README.md
- CHANGELOG.md
- CONTRIBUTING.md
- LICENSE
- package.json
- Configuration files (*.config.mjs, *.yaml)
Expected Location: docs/planning/product-planning-checklist.md
- Rationale: All documentation lives in docs/ with category subdirectories
- Pattern: docs/ide-info/, docs/installers-bundlers/
- New category needed: docs/planning/ (does not currently exist)

⚠️ BMAD Integration

Current State: ZERO BMAD-specific references
Content Type: Generic product planning checklist
Overlap: Significant overlap with existing BMAD workflows:
- Product Brief workflow (src/modules/bmm/workflows/1-analysis/product-brief/)
- Research workflow (src/modules/bmm/workflows/1-analysis/research/)
- PRD workflow (src/modules/bmm/workflows/2-plan-workflows/prd/)
- Tech Spec workflow (src/modules/bmm/workflows/2-plan-workflows/tech-spec/)

Quality Issues

Trailing Whitespace (148 occurrences)

.patch/826/PR-826.patch:30: trailing whitespace.
.patch/826/PR-826.patch:31: trailing whitespace.
.patch/826/PR-826.patch:32: trailing whitespace.
...

Lines Affected: Throughout the entire 147-line document

Why This Matters:

Violates project Prettier configuration
Adds noise to git diffs
Fails CI checks (npm run format:check)

Fix Required: Run npx prettier --write on the file

Convention Violations

Root Directory Placement

BMAD Documentation Structure:

/                           # Root - Config files only
├── README.md              ✅ Allowed
├── CHANGELOG.md           ✅ Allowed
├── CONTRIBUTING.md        ✅ Allowed
├── package.json           ✅ Allowed
└── docs/                  # All documentation
    ├── ide-info/          # IDE-specific guides (15 files)
    ├── installers-bundlers/  # Technical guides (3 files)
    └── *.md               # General guides (4 files)

Violation: high-level-product-plan.md placed at root instead of docs/

Precedent: ALL 46 documentation files live in docs/ with 100% consistency

Recommendation: Create docs/planning/ category and relocate to:

docs/planning/product-planning-checklist.md

Integration Gaps

BMAD-Specific Content Missing

The document is a generic planning checklist with no BMAD integration. See integration-assessment.md for detailed mapping, but key gaps:

Section 1 (Vision/Objectives): Could reference @product-brief workflow
Section 2 (Target Audience): Could reference @research workflow
Section 3 (Feature Planning): Could reference @prd and @tech-spec workflows
Section 4 (Technical Architecture): Could reference @architecture workflow
Section 5 (Resources/Timeline): Could reference @sprint-planning workflow
Section 6 (Market Analysis): Could reference @research --market command
Section 7 (Risk Management): Could reference @solutioning-gate-check workflow
Section 8 (Success Metrics): Could reference workflow status tracking

Current Value: Generic guide for any product team
Potential Value: BMAD-aware guide showing how to use BMAD workflows for each step

Link Validation

✅ No broken links detected (file contains no internal references)

Schema Validation

✅ N/A - This is a Markdown documentation file, not an agent/workflow YAML requiring schema validation

Decision Factors

Accept or Reject?

Reasons to ACCEPT:

Content is valuable - comprehensive planning checklist
No technical errors (valid Markdown)
Fills gap in BMAD documentation (planning guidance)
Easy fixes (whitespace cleanup, relocation)
Contributor effort is significant and well-intentioned

Reasons to REQUEST CHANGES:

Root placement violates 100% consistent convention
148 trailing whitespace errors fail CI
Zero BMAD integration reduces value to BMAD users
Creates precedent for generic content without methodology integration

Recommendation: REQUEST CHANGES with specific relocation path and optional enhancement suggestions

Required Changes

1. File Relocation (REQUIRED)

From: /high-level-product-plan.md
To: docs/planning/product-planning-checklist.md

Steps:

Create docs/planning/ directory (new category)
Move file to new location
Rename to product-planning-checklist.md (kebab-case, descriptive)

2. Code Style Fix (REQUIRED)

Command: npx prettier --write docs/planning/product-planning-checklist.md
Impact: Removes 148 trailing whitespace errors

Optional Enhancements

Add BMAD Integration Section (OPTIONAL - 1 hour effort)

Approach: Add a new section at the end showing how BMAD workflows map to the checklist:

## Using BMAD for Product Planning

This checklist can be executed using BMAD workflows. Here's how each section maps to BMAD commands:

### Phase 1: Discovery & Vision

- **Vision & Objectives** → `@product-brief` - Generate comprehensive product brief
- **Target Audience** → `@research --user` - User research and personas
- **Market Analysis** → `@research --market` - Market research and competitor analysis

### Phase 2: Planning & Specification

- **Feature Planning** → `@prd` - Product Requirements Document generation
- **Technical Architecture** → `@architecture` - Technical architecture planning
- **Resources & Timeline** → `@sprint-planning` - Sprint planning and estimation

### Phase 3: Validation & Risk Management

- **Risk Management** → `@solutioning-gate-check` - Architecture and risk validation
- **Success Metrics** → Workflow status tracking in `.bmad/status.yaml`

For details on any workflow, run:

```bash
bmad-cli workflow --info <workflow-name>
```


**Benefits:**
- Makes generic content BMAD-specific
- Provides practical CLI usage examples
- Demonstrates BMAD workflow coverage
- Preserves original contributor content

**Effort:** ~1 hour (see integration-assessment.md for full analysis)

---

## Next Steps

1. ✅ Document findings (this file)
2. 🔄 Create recommendation.md with decision rationale
3. 🔄 Draft PR review comment with:
   - Thank contributor for effort
   - Explain BMAD documentation conventions
   - Provide specific relocation path
   - Offer optional BMAD integration example
4. 🔄 Post review to GitHub PR #826
5. 🔄 Clean up workspace and revert to v6-alpha

---

## Files Generated

- `.patch/826/syntax-analysis.md` - Markdown syntax validation
- `.patch/826/convention-analysis.md` - BMAD documentation structure
- `.patch/826/integration-assessment.md` - Section-by-section BMAD mapping
- `.patch/826/validation-findings.md` - This file

---

**Status:** VALIDATION COMPLETE - Ready for recommendation phase

7.7 KiB Raw Blame History