BMAD-METHOD/_experiment/planning/roadmap/task-12-tighten-step-04-review.md

Task 12: Tighten Step 4 — Review

Prerequisite

Step 3 test/eval cycle complete. Findings indicate step 4 needs tightening.

Intent

Add specificity to step-04-review.md. This is the highest-risk step. Reference _experiment/planning/redesign-plan.md Step 4 section.

Likely areas

• Context isolation for review subagents (does it actually strip context?)
• Layer 1 vs Layer 2 separation
• Classification cascade (intent > spec > patch)
• INTENT_GAP two-question test
• Spec loop mechanics (frozen sections, change log ratchet, positive preservation)
• Iteration cap enforcement

Constraint

This step has the most detailed plan material. Resist the urge to dump it all in. Add only what testing proves is needed.