ldy26098
/
BMAD-METHOD
mirror of https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD.git
1
0
Fork 0
Code Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
BMAD-METHOD/bmad-claude-integration/tests/scenarios/bmad-success-metrics.md

4.7 KiB
Raw Blame History

BMAD-METHOD Claude Code Integration Success Metrics

Critical Functionality Metrics

1. Agent Routing Accuracy

  • Target: 95%+ correct agent routing based on user request
  • Measurement: Percentage of requests routed to appropriate BMAD agent
  • Failure Threshold: < 80% accuracy
  • Test Method: Present 100 varied requests, measure routing decisions

2. Context Preservation

  • Target: 100% context preservation across agent handoffs
  • Measurement: All initial constraints, requirements, and files maintained
  • Failure Threshold: Any loss of critical context
  • Test Method: Complex multi-agent workflows with context verification

3. Elicitation Flow

  • Target: 100% natural conversation flow
  • Measurement: No special syntax required, clear agent identification
  • Failure Threshold: User confusion about response format or current agent
  • Test Method: User study with elicitation scenarios

4. Concurrent Session Management

  • Target: Support 5+ concurrent agent sessions
  • Measurement: Session isolation, switching speed, state preservation
  • Failure Threshold: Session cross-contamination or state loss
  • Test Method: Stress test with multiple active sessions

5. Response Time

  • Target: < 2 seconds for agent routing, < 5 seconds for response
  • Measurement: Time from request to first agent response
  • Failure Threshold: > 10 seconds for any operation
  • Test Method: Performance benchmarking

BMAD-Specific Functionality

6. Story Creation Quality (PM Agent)

  • Target: 90%+ acceptance rate for generated user stories
  • Measurement: Stories meet INVEST criteria, proper format
  • Failure Threshold: < 70% meet basic story criteria
  • Test Method: Generate 20 stories, evaluate with checklist

7. Architecture Design Completeness (Architect Agent)

  • Target: 100% coverage of required architectural components
  • Measurement: Presence of all template sections, technical accuracy
  • Failure Threshold: Missing critical architectural elements
  • Test Method: Generate architectures for standard patterns

8. Workflow Completion

  • Target: 85%+ successful end-to-end workflow completion
  • Measurement: From initial request to final deliverable
  • Failure Threshold: < 60% completion rate
  • Test Method: Execute full BMAD workflows

9. Checklist Execution

  • Target: 100% checklist item coverage
  • Measurement: All checklist items addressed in output
  • Failure Threshold: Skipped checklist items without justification
  • Test Method: Run all BMAD checklists

10. Template Adherence

  • Target: 95%+ template structure compliance
  • Measurement: Generated documents match template format
  • Failure Threshold: < 80% template compliance
  • Test Method: Compare outputs to templates

User Experience Metrics

11. Agent Identification Clarity

  • Target: 100% clear agent identification in all interactions
  • Measurement: User always knows which agent they're talking to
  • Failure Threshold: Any ambiguity about active agent
  • Test Method: User feedback survey

12. Command Discovery

  • Target: 90%+ command discovery rate
  • Measurement: Users find and use appropriate commands
  • Failure Threshold: < 70% discovery rate
  • Test Method: New user testing

13. Error Recovery

  • Target: 100% graceful error handling
  • Measurement: Clear error messages, recovery suggestions
  • Failure Threshold: Cryptic errors or system crashes
  • Test Method: Error injection testing

Installation & Setup

14. Installation Success Rate

  • Target: 95%+ successful installations
  • Measurement: Complete installation without manual intervention
  • Failure Threshold: < 80% success rate
  • Test Method: Fresh installation on various systems

15. Upstream Compatibility

  • Target: 100% compatibility with BMAD-METHOD updates
  • Measurement: No modifications to original BMAD files
  • Failure Threshold: Any required changes to upstream files
  • Test Method: Diff analysis after updates

Success Criteria Summary

Overall Success: Meeting or exceeding targets on 13/15 metrics Partial Success: Meeting targets on 10-12 metrics Failure: Meeting fewer than 10 metric targets

Testing Priority

  1. Critical Path (Must Pass):

    • Context Preservation (100%)
    • Elicitation Flow (100%)
    • Agent Identification (100%)
    • Upstream Compatibility (100%)

  2. High Priority (>90% target):

    • Agent Routing Accuracy
    • Template Adherence
    • Installation Success

  3. Standard Priority (>85% target):

    • Story Creation Quality
    • Workflow Completion
    • Command Discovery

  4. Performance (Time-based):

    • Response Time
    • Session Management