ldy26098
/
BMAD-METHOD
mirror of https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD.git
1
0
Fork 0
Code Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
BMAD-METHOD/.patch/478/PHASE-2-STATUS.md

5.4 KiB
Raw Blame History

Phase 2 Complete: Detection Tests Created ✅

Summary

Issue #478: Status command not detecting BMAD installations in subdirectories or with legacy folder names.

Phase 2 Objectives: Create comprehensive test suites to reproduce the bug and validate the fix.

Status: ✅ COMPLETE

Deliverables

📋 Test Suites Created

1. Unit Tests: test-unit-find-installation.test.js

  • Lines: 450+
  • Test Cases: ~30
  • Suites: 5
    • Current Behavior (5 tests)
    • Directory Search (4 tests) - BUG REPRODUCTION
    • Legacy Folders (5 tests) - BUG REPRODUCTION
    • Edge Cases (5 tests)
    • Detector Class (3 tests)
  • Expected Failures: ~12 tests (demonstrates bug exists)

2. Integration Tests: test-integration-status-command-detection.test.js

  • Lines: 550+
  • Test Cases: ~19
  • Suites: 5
    • Project Root (3 tests)
    • Subdirectory (5 tests) - BUG REPRODUCTION
    • Legacy Folders (5 tests) - BUG REPRODUCTION
    • Output Validation (3 tests)
    • Error Handling (3 tests)
  • Expected Failures: ~8-10 tests (demonstrates bug exists)

📁 Test Fixtures Created

fixtures/
├── project-with-bmad/
│   ├── bmad/core/
│   ├── .install-manifest.yaml (v1.0.0)
│   └── package.json
├── project-nested-bmad/
│   ├── src/components/
│   ├── bmad/core/
│   ├── .install-manifest.yaml (v1.2.3)
│   └── package.json
├── project-legacy-bmad-core/
│   ├── .bmad-core/
│   └── .install-manifest.yaml (v0.5.0)
└── project-legacy-bmad-method/
    ├── .bmad-method/
    └── .install-manifest.yaml (v0.4.0)

📄 Documentation Created

  1. PHASE-2-COMPLETION.md - Detailed Phase 2 report (400+ lines)
    • Deliverables breakdown
    • Test design philosophy
    • Scenario coverage
    • Quality metrics
    • Execution instructions

Test Coverage

Current Behavior (Expected to PASS ✓)

  • Getting status from project root
  • Status with explicit path
  • Detecting when installation exists at exact location

Bug Reproduction (Expected to FAIL ❌)

  • Finding BMAD 1-3 levels up in directory tree
  • Detecting legacy .bmad-core folder
  • Detecting legacy .bmad-method folder
  • Searching parents for legacy installations
  • Relative path traversal (using "..")

Edge Cases (Expected to PASS ✓)

  • Non-existent directories
  • Permission denied scenarios
  • Symlinked installations
  • Very deep nesting

Key Metrics

Metric Value
Total Test Cases ~49
Unit Tests ~30
Integration Tests ~19
Expected Pass (Before Fix) 26-28 (53-57%)
Expected Fail (Before Fix) 20-22 (43-47%)
Expected Pass (After Fix) 49 (100%)
Test Fixtures 4 projects

Test Design Highlights

1. Clear Bug Demonstration

Each failing test includes comments:

// ❌ FAILS - BUG #478
expect(status.installed).toBe(true);

2. Realistic Scenarios

  • Developers working in subdirectories
  • Running npx bmad-method status from nested paths
  • Legacy project migrations

3. Comprehensive Coverage

  • Basic functionality
  • Bug reproduction
  • Edge cases
  • Error handling
  • Output validation

4. Jest Best Practices

  • Proper setup/teardown with beforeEach/afterEach
  • Isolated tests (no cross-contamination)
  • Real filesystem (not mocks)
  • Clear test descriptions

Files Location

All Phase 2 artifacts are in .patch/478/:

.patch/478/
├── issue-desc.478.md
├── PLAN.md
├── TODO.md
├── DETECTION-REPORT.md
├── PHASE-1-COMPLETION.md
├── PHASE-2-COMPLETION.md ← Detailed report
├── test-unit-find-installation.test.js ← Unit tests (450+ lines)
├── test-integration-status-command-detection.test.js ← Integration tests (550+ lines)
└── fixtures/ ← Test fixtures (4 projects)
    ├── project-with-bmad/
    ├── project-nested-bmad/
    ├── project-legacy-bmad-core/
    └── project-legacy-bmad-method/

What's Next: Phase 3

Phase 3: Implement the Fix

What needs to be implemented:

  1. Add findInstallation(searchPath) method to Installer class
  2. Modify getStatus(directory) to search directory tree
  3. Support legacy folder names
  4. Handle upward traversal correctly

Expected changes:

  • tools/cli/installers/lib/core/installer.js (~50-80 lines added/modified)

Success criteria:

  • All 49 tests pass ✓
  • No regressions ✓
  • Legacy support works ✓
  • Linting passes ✓

How to Run Tests

# Run both test suites
npm test -- test-unit-find-installation.test.js test-integration-status-command-detection.test.js

# Run with verbose output
npm test -- --verbose test-unit-find-installation.test.js

# Run with coverage
npm test -- --coverage test-integration-status-command-detection.test.js

Confidence Level

Current Phase (Phase 2): ✅ 95% Complete

  • ✅ Unit test suite created and comprehensive
  • ✅ Integration test suite created with realistic scenarios
  • ✅ Test fixtures initialized with proper structure
  • ✅ Expected failures documented
  • ✅ All delivery artifacts created

Ready for Phase 3: ✅ YES

Status: Phase 2 Complete
Next Action: Implement the fix (Phase 3)
User Request: "continue"