BMAD-METHOD/bmad-core/tasks/create-scorecard.md

create-scorecard

Generate BMAD Opportunity Scorecard for market opportunities or feature ideas.

Execution Framework

1. Opportunity Definition

   • Define the specific opportunity or feature
   • Establish target customer segment
   • Clarify success metrics

2. Market Analysis Scoring (1-5 scale)

   • Market Size: Total addressable market potential
   • Growth Rate: Market expansion velocity
   • Competition: Competitive density and strength
   • Timing: Market readiness and external factors

3. Implementation Feasibility (1-5 scale)

   • Technical Complexity: Development difficulty
   • Resource Requirements: Team and budget needs
   • Time to Market: Speed of delivery
   • Risk Level: Technical and market risks

4. Strategic Fit (1-5 scale)

   • Business Model Alignment: Revenue model fit
   • Core Competency Match: Team capability alignment
   • Competitive Advantage: Defensibility potential
   • Customer Value: Benefit magnitude

5. Generate Scorecard Output

   OPPORTUNITY SCORECARD
   Opportunity: [Name]
   
   MARKET ATTRACTIVENESS (Total: /20)
   - Market Size: [X]/5
   - Growth Rate: [X]/5  
   - Competition: [X]/5
   - Timing: [X]/5
   
   IMPLEMENTATION FEASIBILITY (Total: /20)
   - Technical Complexity: [X]/5
   - Resource Requirements: [X]/5
   - Time to Market: [X]/5
   - Risk Level: [X]/5
   
   STRATEGIC FIT (Total: /20)
   - Business Model Alignment: [X]/5
   - Core Competency Match: [X]/5
   - Competitive Advantage: [X]/5
   - Customer Value: [X]/5
   
   OVERALL SCORE: [X]/60
   RECOMMENDATION: [Go/No-Go/Investigate Further]
   

Data Sources

• Market data from bmad-core/data/market-sizes.csv
• Competitive intelligence from competitive-benchmarks.csv
• User-provided opportunity details

Validation Criteria

• All scores justified with evidence
• Recommendations align with scoring
• Clear next steps provided