BMAD-METHOD/_experiment/planning/roadmap/task-14-eval-step-04-review.md

Task 14: Eval Step 4 — Review Efficiency

Prerequisite

Task 13 test cycle clean.

Intent

Evaluate review quality and efficiency.

Metrics

• Finding quality (real issues vs noise)
• Classification accuracy (spec vs patch vs defer — are they right?)
• Spec loop iterations used vs cap
• Tokens consumed in review (especially spec loop cost)
• Compare review quality against QD step-05 adversarial review baseline
• False positive rate (reject-class findings as % of total)

Output

Eval report: _experiment/results/step-04-eval.md.