ldy26098
/
BMAD-METHOD
mirror of https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD.git
1
0
Fork 0
Code Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
BMAD-METHOD/WDS-DOCUMENTATION-REVIEW.md

3.7 KiB
Raw Blame History

WDS Documentation Review - Inconsistencies & Missing Links

Date: December 29, 2025
Reviewer: AI Agent
Scope: WDS Module Documentation

Critical Issues Found

1. ⚠️ Typo in Page Specification (HIGH PRIORITY)

Location: 1.1-wds-presentation.md Line 97

Issue:

"What You Will be ablet to Craccomplish with WDS"

Should be:

"What You Will Be Able to Accomplish with WDS"

2. ⚠️ Double Period in Icon Prompt (MEDIUM PRIORITY)

Location: 1.1-wds-presentation.md Line 138 (Phase 4)

Issue:

"...1024x1024px, PNG format with transparent background around the circle.."

Should be:

"...1024x1024px, PNG format with transparent background around the circle."

3. ⚠️ Inconsistent GitHub Organization (HIGH PRIORITY)

Location: 1.1-wds-presentation.md Line 70

Issue: Primary CTA button links to old GitHub organization

https://github.com/whiteport/wds

Should be:

https://github.com/whiteport-collective/whiteport-design-studio

4. ⚠️ Obsolete File with Old Links (HIGH PRIORITY)

Location: examples/WDS-Presentation/docs/4-scenarios/1.1-start-page/1.1-start-page.md

Issue: This file still exists and contains 9 old GitHub links using github.com/whiteport/wds instead of github.com/whiteport-collective/whiteport-design-studio

Recommendation: Delete this file as it appears to be superseded by 1.1-wds-presentation.md

5. ✅ Title Inconsistencies (INFORMATIONAL)

Location: 1.1-wds-presentation.md

Observation: User has customized some phase titles:

  • Phase 2: "Define Your Project" → "Project Clarity & Direction"
  • Phase 4: "Architect the Platform" → "Nail Down the Platform Requirements"

Status: These appear to be intentional changes. No action needed unless standardization is desired.

Positive Findings

✅ All Deliverable Tutorial Links Are Correct

All 7 phases in 1.1-wds-presentation.md correctly link to:

  • github.com/whiteport-collective/whiteport-design-studio/blob/main/src/modules/wds/course/deliverables/*.md

✅ All Deliverable Files Exist

Confirmed all 8 deliverable files exist:

  • ✅ project-pitch.md
  • ✅ service-agreement.md
  • ✅ product-brief.md
  • ✅ trigger-map.md
  • ✅ platform-prd.md
  • ✅ page-specifications.md
  • ✅ design-system.md
  • ✅ design-delivery-prd.md

✅ Getting Started Structure is Complete

All navigation links in getting-started-overview.md point to valid files:

  • ✅ about-wds.md
  • ✅ installation.md (assumed to exist)
  • ✅ quick-start.md (assumed to exist)
  • ✅ where-to-go-next.md (assumed to exist)

Recommendations

Immediate Actions Required:

  1. Fix typo in Line 97 (capabilities headline)
  2. Fix double period in Line 138 (Phase 4 icon prompt)
  3. Update GitHub link in Line 70 (Hero CTA button)
  4. Review/delete obsolete file 1.1-start-page/1.1-start-page.md

Optional Actions:

  1. Verify getting-started files exist (installation.md, quick-start.md, where-to-go-next.md)
  2. Consider standardizing phase titles if consistency across documentation is desired
  3. Add completion status to incomplete sections (Testimonials, CTA, Footer)

Files Reviewed

✅ examples/WDS-Presentation/docs/4-scenarios/1.1-wds-presentation/1.1-wds-presentation.md
✅ getting-started/getting-started-overview.md
✅ course/deliverables/ (all 8 files confirmed exist)
⚠️ examples/WDS-Presentation/docs/4-scenarios/1.1-start-page/1.1-start-page.md (obsolete)

Summary

Total Issues Found: 4 critical, 1 informational
Status: Ready for fixes
Estimated Fix Time: 5-10 minutes