diff --git a/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/BMM_AGENTS_VCS_CONFIG_PATH_FIX.md b/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/BMM_AGENTS_VCS_CONFIG_PATH_FIX.md deleted file mode 100644 index 4624991b..00000000 --- a/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/BMM_AGENTS_VCS_CONFIG_PATH_FIX.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,498 +0,0 @@ -# BMAD-METHOD Path Fix Plan - -**Created:** 2025-10-01 17:45:00 EEST -**Repository:** ~/github/BMAD-METHOD -**Branch:** feat/bmvcs-dev -**Issue:** Path inconsistency in BMM agents VCS integration - ---- - -## Executive Summary - -**Problem:** BMM agents look for VCS config at wrong path - -- **Expected (BMVCS):** `.bmad/vcs-config.yaml` -- **Actual (Agents):** `bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml` -- **Impact:** VCS integration doesn't work without manual workaround - -**Solution:** Update 3 agent source files to use correct path - -**Estimated Time:** 15 minutes - ---- - -## Current State Analysis - -### Repository Info - -- **Location:** `~/github/BMAD-METHOD` -- **Current Branch:** `feat/bmvcs-dev` -- **Last Commit:** `84920e1` - chore(bmvcs): remove testing notes -- **Origin:** `https://github.com/oblik-io/BMAD-METHOD.git` (your fork) -- **Upstream:** `https://github.com/bmad-code-org/BMAD-METHOD.git` (main repo) -- **Status:** Has uncommitted change in `package-lock.json` - -### PR Status - -- **Existing PR:** To `github.com/joyshmitz/BMAD-METHOD` (mentioned by user) -- **Note:** No PR visible to oblik-io/BMAD-METHOD via `gh pr list` -- **Implication:** May need to create PR to oblik-io after fix - -### Affected Files (Source) - -Located in: `~/github/BMAD-METHOD/src/modules/bmm/agents/` - -1. **architect.md** - Line 68 - - ```xml - Check if VCS configuration exists in bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml - ``` - -2. **pm.md** - Line 68 - - ```xml - Check if VCS configuration exists in bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml - ``` - -3. **dev.md** - Line 73 - ```xml - Check if VCS configuration exists in bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml - ``` - ---- - -## Execution Plan - -### Phase 1: Pre-Fix Verification (5 min) - -#### Step 1.1: Clean Working Directory - -```bash -cd ~/github/BMAD-METHOD -git status -``` - -**Decision Point:** - -- If only `package-lock.json` modified → commit or stash -- If other changes → review and decide - -**Action:** - -```bash -# Option A: Commit package-lock.json -git add package-lock.json -git commit -m "chore: update package-lock.json" - -# Option B: Stash -git stash push -m "WIP: package-lock.json before path fix" -``` - -#### Step 1.2: Verify Current Branch - -```bash -git branch --show-current -# Expected: feat/bmvcs-dev -``` - -#### Step 1.3: Backup Current State - -```bash -git log -1 --oneline > /tmp/bmad-before-fix.txt -git diff HEAD -- src/modules/bmm/agents/ > /tmp/bmad-agents-before.diff -``` - ---- - -### Phase 2: Apply Fix (5 min) - -#### Step 2.1: Update architect.md - -```bash -cd ~/github/BMAD-METHOD -``` - -**File:** `src/modules/bmm/agents/architect.md` -**Line:** 68 - -**Change:** - -```diff -- Check if VCS configuration exists in bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml -+ Check if VCS configuration exists in .bmad/vcs-config.yaml -``` - -**Full context (lines 68-72):** - -```xml -Check if VCS configuration exists in .bmad/vcs-config.yaml -→ GitHub Flow: lightweight docs focusing on individual PRs -→ GitFlow: version-oriented documentation with release cycles -→ Trunk-Based: flag-gated incremental documentation -→ No VCS: comprehensive monolithic documentation -``` - -#### Step 2.2: Update pm.md - -**File:** `src/modules/bmm/agents/pm.md` -**Line:** 68 - -**Change:** - -```diff -- Check if VCS configuration exists in bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml -+ Check if VCS configuration exists in .bmad/vcs-config.yaml -``` - -**Full context (lines 68-72):** - -```xml -Check if VCS configuration exists in .bmad/vcs-config.yaml -→ GitHub Flow: feature-scoped PRDs with 1-3 day stories -→ GitFlow: release-scoped PRDs with 3-5 day stories and versioning -→ Trunk-Based: flag-gated increments with <1 day stories -→ No VCS: comprehensive upfront requirements -``` - -#### Step 2.3: Update dev.md - -**File:** `src/modules/bmm/agents/dev.md` -**Line:** 73 - -**Change:** - -```diff -- Check if VCS configuration exists in bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml -+ Check if VCS configuration exists in .bmad/vcs-config.yaml -``` - -**Full context (lines 73-77):** - -```xml -Check if VCS configuration exists in .bmad/vcs-config.yaml -→ GitHub Flow: atomic commits with conventional commit style -→ GitFlow: descriptive commits with branch prefixes -→ Trunk-Based: feature-flag wrapped changes with frequent commits -→ No VCS: complete packaged code delivery -``` - ---- - -### Phase 3: Verification (3 min) - -#### Step 3.1: Verify Changes - -```bash -cd ~/github/BMAD-METHOD -git diff src/modules/bmm/agents/architect.md -git diff src/modules/bmm/agents/pm.md -git diff src/modules/bmm/agents/dev.md -``` - -**Expected output for each file:** - -- One line changed: `bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml` → `.bmad/vcs-config.yaml` -- Context preserved -- No other changes - -#### Step 3.2: Check Line Numbers - -```bash -grep -n "\.bmad/vcs-config\.yaml" src/modules/bmm/agents/architect.md -grep -n "\.bmad/vcs-config\.yaml" src/modules/bmm/agents/pm.md -grep -n "\.bmad/vcs-config\.yaml" src/modules/bmm/agents/dev.md -``` - -**Expected:** - -- architect.md:68 -- pm.md:68 -- dev.md:73 - -#### Step 3.3: Verify No Other Files Affected - -```bash -git status -``` - -**Expected:** Only 3 files modified: - -- `src/modules/bmm/agents/architect.md` -- `src/modules/bmm/agents/pm.md` -- `src/modules/bmm/agents/dev.md` - ---- - -### Phase 4: Commit & Push (2 min) - -#### Step 4.1: Stage Changes - -```bash -cd ~/github/BMAD-METHOD -git add src/modules/bmm/agents/architect.md -git add src/modules/bmm/agents/pm.md -git add src/modules/bmm/agents/dev.md -``` - -#### Step 4.2: Commit - -```bash -git commit -m "$(cat <<'EOF' -fix(bmm): correct VCS config path in Architect/PM/Dev agents - -ISSUE: Path Inconsistency -BMM agents were looking for VCS config at wrong path: -- Old: bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml (incorrect) -- New: .bmad/vcs-config.yaml (correct per BMVCS spec) - -IMPACT: -VCS integration failed without manual workaround (copy config to both locations) - -FIX: -Updated 3 agent files to use correct path: -- src/modules/bmm/agents/architect.md (line 68) -- src/modules/bmm/agents/pm.md (line 68) -- src/modules/bmm/agents/dev.md (line 73) - -TESTING: -Discovered during BMVCS Alpha Phase 2 testing (sections 2.6-2.7) -- Test repo: ~/test-bmvcs-install -- Test results: testing/12-ALPHA-ARCHITECT-INTEGRATION-SECTION-2-6.md -- Workaround documented, now properly fixed in source - -AFFECTED AGENTS: -✅ Architect - VCS-aware documentation generation -✅ PM - VCS-aware requirements planning -✅ Dev - VCS-aware implementation guidance -❌ SM - No VCS integration (by design) -❌ TEA - No VCS integration (by design) - -This fix enables seamless VCS integration without manual intervention. - -Related: feat/bmvcs-dev branch development -Testing: Alpha Phase 2 complete (2025-10-01) -EOF -)" -``` - -#### Step 4.3: Push to Origin - -```bash -git push origin feat/bmvcs-dev -``` - -**Result:** Updates existing branch on `oblik-io/BMAD-METHOD` - ---- - -### Phase 5: Test in test-bmvcs-install (Optional, 10 min) - -**Purpose:** Verify fix works in test environment - -#### Step 5.1: Reinstall BMAD-METHOD in Test Repo - -```bash -cd ~/test-bmvcs-install - -# Option A: Full reinstall -# rm -rf .claude/commands/bmad -# cd ~/github/BMAD-METHOD && npm run install - -# Option B: Copy only updated agents -cp ~/github/BMAD-METHOD/src/modules/bmm/agents/architect.md .claude/commands/bmad/bmm/agents/ -cp ~/github/BMAD-METHOD/src/modules/bmm/agents/pm.md .claude/commands/bmad/bmm/agents/ -cp ~/github/BMAD-METHOD/src/modules/bmm/agents/dev.md .claude/commands/bmad/bmm/agents/ -``` - -#### Step 5.2: Remove Workaround - -```bash -cd ~/test-bmvcs-install -rm -rf bmad-core/ -``` - -#### Step 5.3: Test Integration - -```bash -# Create simple test document -cat > test-fix.md <<'EOF' -# Test Architecture - -Simple test to verify VCS integration. -EOF - -# Test with Architect agent (in new Claude Code session) -# Command: /bmad:bmm:agents:architect -# Request: "Adapt this document for our VCS workflow" -``` - -**Expected Result:** - -- Agent reads `.bmad/vcs-config.yaml` ✅ -- No error about missing config ✅ -- Document adapted per workflow ✅ -- No manual workaround needed ✅ - ---- - -## Post-Fix Actions - -### Immediate (After Phase 4) - -1. **Update PR Description** (if PR exists to joyshmitz/BMAD-METHOD) - - Add note about path fix - - Reference Alpha testing results - - Link to fix commit - -2. **Consider Creating PR to oblik-io/BMAD-METHOD** - ```bash - cd ~/github/BMAD-METHOD - gh pr create --base main --head feat/bmvcs-dev \ - --title "feat(bmvcs): VCS Adapter with path fix" \ - --body "Includes path inconsistency fix discovered in Alpha testing" - ``` - -### Follow-up (Next Session) - -1. **Document Fix in Test Results** - - Update `~/test-bmvcs-install/SESSION_END_PHASE_2_COMPLETE_2025-10-01.md` - - Add "Fixed in source" status - -2. **Clean Up Test Workaround** - - ```bash - cd ~/test-bmvcs-install - rm -rf bmad-core/ - git add bmad-core/ - git commit -m "chore: remove VCS config workaround after upstream fix" - ``` - -3. **Update TESTING_STATUS.md** - - Mark path issue as "✅ FIXED in source" - - Update status from "⚠️ Workaround" to "✅ Resolved" - ---- - -## Risk Assessment - -### Low Risk ✅ - -- **Change scope:** Only 3 files, 1 line each -- **Change type:** String literal (path) -- **Testing:** Extensively tested in Alpha Phase 2 -- **Rollback:** Simple git revert if needed - -### Medium Risk ⚠️ - -- **Integration:** Requires BMVCS to be present -- **Backwards compat:** Old installations will break (acceptable - alpha) - -### High Risk ❌ - -- None identified - ---- - -## Rollback Plan - -If fix causes issues: - -```bash -cd ~/github/BMAD-METHOD -git revert HEAD -git push origin feat/bmvcs-dev -``` - -Or targeted rollback: - -```bash -git checkout HEAD~1 -- src/modules/bmm/agents/architect.md -git checkout HEAD~1 -- src/modules/bmm/agents/pm.md -git checkout HEAD~1 -- src/modules/bmm/agents/dev.md -git commit -m "revert: rollback VCS config path change" -``` - ---- - -## Success Criteria - -✅ **Phase 1:** Clean working directory, verified branch -✅ **Phase 2:** All 3 files updated correctly -✅ **Phase 3:** Changes verified, no unintended modifications -✅ **Phase 4:** Committed and pushed to origin -✅ **Phase 5:** (Optional) Tested in test-bmvcs-install - -**Definition of Done:** - -- [ ] 3 agent files updated with correct path -- [ ] Commit created with detailed message -- [ ] Pushed to origin/feat/bmvcs-dev -- [ ] No breaking changes introduced -- [ ] (Optional) Verified in test environment - ---- - -## Notes from Alpha Testing - -**Source:** `~/test-bmvcs-install/testing/12-ALPHA-ARCHITECT-INTEGRATION-SECTION-2-6.md` - -**Discovery Context:** - -- Section 2.6: Architect Agent Integration testing -- Date: 2025-10-01 15:40:00 EEST -- Workaround: `cp .bmad/vcs-config.yaml bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml` - -**Test Results:** - -- GitHub Flow adaptation: 65 → 262 lines (+303%) -- GitFlow adaptation: 65 → 410 lines (+531%) -- Integration works with workaround -- Value proposition validated: 99%+ time savings - -**Recommendation:** -Fix in source (BMAD-METHOD repo) rather than test repo - ---- - -## Timeline Estimate - -| Phase | Task | Time | -| --------------- | -------------------- | ---------- | -| 1 | Pre-fix verification | 5 min | -| 2 | Apply fix (3 files) | 5 min | -| 3 | Verification | 3 min | -| 4 | Commit & push | 2 min | -| **Total** | **Core fix** | **15 min** | -| 5 | Optional testing | +10 min | -| **Grand Total** | **With testing** | **25 min** | - ---- - -## Checklist for Next Session - -**Before Starting:** - -- [ ] Read this plan document -- [ ] Verify still on `feat/bmvcs-dev` branch -- [ ] Check no conflicting changes - -**During Execution:** - -- [ ] Follow phases sequentially -- [ ] Verify each step before proceeding -- [ ] Document any deviations - -**After Completion:** - -- [ ] Verify push successful -- [ ] Update test repo status -- [ ] Mark issue as resolved in session docs - ---- - -**Plan Status:** READY FOR EXECUTION -**Recommended Session:** Fresh session with full context -**Prerequisites:** None (all info in this plan) - -**Generated:** 2025-10-01 17:45:00 EEST -**Testing Reference:** ~/test-bmvcs-install/SESSION_END_PHASE_2_COMPLETE_2025-10-01.md diff --git a/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/DEVELOPMENT_APPROACH.md b/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/DEVELOPMENT_APPROACH.md deleted file mode 100644 index fa53e0a7..00000000 --- a/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/DEVELOPMENT_APPROACH.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,310 +0,0 @@ -# BMVCS Development Approach - -**Document Type:** Module Development Analysis -**Status:** Retrospective Analysis -**Version:** 1.0.0 -**Date:** 2025-09-30 - ---- - -## Overview - -This document analyzes the development approach used for creating the BMVCS module and compares it with the standard BMB (BMAD Builder) `create-module` workflow introduced in BMAD v6. - ---- - -## Module Creation Strategy - -BMVCS was developed using a **direct development approach** rather than the standard BMB `create-module` workflow. This was an intentional choice that proved beneficial for this specific module. - ---- - -## Why Direct Development? - -### Advantages for BMVCS - -The direct development approach provided several key benefits: - -#### 1. Speed - -- Rapid prototyping without multi-step wizard overhead -- Immediate implementation of ideas -- No waiting for workflow prompts -- Fast iteration cycles - -#### 2. Flexibility - -- Freedom to experiment with VCS-agnostic concepts -- Ability to deviate from standard patterns when needed -- Custom structure for unique requirements -- Real-time architectural decisions - -#### 3. Customization - -- Unique structure tailored to specific needs -- Custom VCS adaptation templates system -- Innovative confidence scoring mechanism -- Specialized discovery task patterns - -#### 4. Innovation - -- Space to develop new patterns -- Discovery tasks with interactive prompts -- Adapter agent paradigm -- Template-based workflow adaptations - ---- - -## When to Use Each Approach - -### Use Direct Development When: - -✓ You have clear vision of the module structure -✓ Experimenting with new concepts or patterns -✓ Working in alpha/research mode -✓ Need fast iteration cycles -✓ Creating innovative/non-standard modules -✓ Have deep understanding of BMAD v6 architecture - -### Use BMB create-module When: - -✓ First time creating a BMAD module -✓ Need guided process with validation -✓ Want guaranteed v6 compatibility -✓ Prefer scaffolding over manual creation -✓ Building standard domain modules -✓ Want automatic roadmap and TODO generation - ---- - -## BMVCS vs BMB Standards Compliance - -Despite bypassing the BMB workflow, BMVCS fully adheres to BMAD v6 module standards: - -| Component | BMB Standard | BMVCS Implementation | Status | -| -------------------- | ----------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------- | ------------ | -| **Structure** | `agents/`, `workflows/`, `tasks/`, `templates/` | All present | ✅ Compliant | -| **Installer** | `_module-installer/` with config | Complete with custom logic | ✅ Compliant | -| **Primary Agent** | Minimum 1 agent | `vcs-adapter.md` | ✅ Compliant | -| **Workflows** | 2-10 workflows | `setup-vcs` workflow | ✅ Compliant | -| **Tasks** | Supporting tasks | 3 tasks (discover, adapt, validate) | ✅ Compliant | -| **Documentation** | README + docs | README + 4 detailed docs | ✅ Compliant | -| **Templates** | Shared resources | 5 VCS adaptation templates | ✅ Compliant | -| **Examples** | Usage examples | Comprehensive examples/ folder | ✅ Compliant | -| **Installer Config** | `install-menu-config.yaml` | Complete configuration | ✅ Compliant | -| **Module Metadata** | Version, status, code | All present in README | ✅ Compliant | - -### Additional Components Beyond Standards - -BMVCS includes components that exceed BMB standards: - -- **Confidence Scoring System** - Novel VCS detection algorithm -- **Adaptation Templates** - YAML-based workflow configurations -- **Interactive Discovery** - Multi-step VCS identification process -- **Integration Hooks** - Optional BMM agent integration points - ---- - -## Comparison: What Each Approach Provides - -### BMB create-module Provides - -**Workflow Features:** - -- Interactive module brainstorming session -- Module brief creation workflow -- Step-by-step component planning -- Automatic directory scaffolding -- Generated configuration files -- Module validation checks -- Development roadmap (TODO.md) -- Post-creation summary - -**Quality Assurance:** - -- Guaranteed v6 structure compliance -- Configuration file templates -- Installer setup automation -- Documentation templates -- Component naming validation - -### Direct Development Provides - -**Flexibility:** - -- Immediate implementation -- Custom architectural patterns -- Experimentation freedom -- Innovation space -- Rapid prototyping - -**Trade-offs:** - -- Manual structure creation -- Self-validation required -- Documentation written from scratch -- Installer logic custom-built - ---- - -## BMVCS Development Timeline - -### Phase 1: Concept & Research - -- Analyzed BMAD v6 architecture changes -- Researched VCS-agnostic approaches -- Studied BMB module structure patterns -- Decided on direct development approach - -### Phase 2: Core Structure - -- Created module directory structure -- Built VCS Adapter agent -- Designed discovery task flow -- Implemented adaptation templates - -### Phase 3: Integration & Testing - -- Developed installer configuration -- Created workflow components -- Built validation mechanisms -- Tested with multiple VCS types - -### Phase 4: Documentation - -- Wrote comprehensive README -- Created principle documents -- Built example implementations -- Added confidence scoring docs - ---- - -## Lessons Learned - -### What Worked Well - -1. **Rapid Prototyping** - - Concepts became implementations quickly - - Easy to pivot when better ideas emerged - - No workflow constraints slowing progress - -2. **Custom Innovation** - - Confidence scoring system emerged naturally - - Template-based adaptations designed iteratively - - Discovery flow refined through experimentation - -3. **Architecture Flexibility** - - Could break conventions when beneficial - - Novel patterns (adapter agent) explored freely - - Integration hooks added organically - -### What Could Be Improved - -1. **Validation Checkpoints** - - Manual verification of BMB compliance needed - - No automatic structure validation - - Self-auditing required - -2. **Documentation Overhead** - - More upfront documentation writing - - No auto-generated component lists - - Manual README maintenance - -3. **Roadmap Management** - - No automatic TODO.md generation - - Manual tracking of remaining work - - Self-managed development phases - ---- - -## Recommendations for Future Modules - -### For Standard Modules - -**Use BMB create-module workflow:** - -- Domain-specific modules (Legal, Medical, Finance, etc.) -- Content creation modules -- Productivity tools -- Game development modules -- Standard agent + workflow combinations - -### For Innovative Modules - -**Consider direct development:** - -- Novel architectural patterns -- Research/experimental modules -- Cross-cutting concerns (like BMVCS) -- Infrastructure modules -- Tool/builder modules - -### Hybrid Approach - -**Combine both methods:** - -1. Use BMB for initial scaffolding -2. Customize structure for special needs -3. Add innovative components manually -4. Leverage BMB validation at end - ---- - -## Key Takeaways - -### Both Approaches Are Valid - -- **BMB create-module** = Scaffolding tool for structured creation -- **Direct development** = Production-ready structure built manually - -### BMVCS Proves a Point - -Understanding BMAD v6 architecture allows successful module creation without mandatory tooling. The direct development approach can be faster and more flexible for experienced developers working on innovative modules. - -### This May Become a Pattern - -The "rapid prototyping pattern" demonstrated by BMVCS development could be documented as an official alternative approach for experienced BMAD module developers. - ---- - -## Future Possibilities - -### Retrospective BMB Validation - -- Run BMB validation tools on existing modules -- Compare hand-built vs generated structures -- Identify gaps or improvements -- Update module to incorporate BMB best practices - -### Tooling Enhancement - -- Create "validate-module" tool for manual modules -- Build "enhance-module" to add BMB features to existing modules -- Develop "module-audit" for compliance checking - -### Documentation Pattern - -- Use BMVCS as case study in BMB documentation -- Show both approaches in module creation guides -- Provide decision matrix for approach selection - ---- - -## Conclusion - -BMVCS demonstrates that direct development is a viable alternative to the BMB create-module workflow for certain types of modules. While BMB provides structure and guidance, direct development offers speed and flexibility for experienced developers working on innovative or experimental modules. - -The key is understanding **when to use which approach** based on: - -- Developer experience level -- Module complexity and novelty -- Need for speed vs structure -- Standard vs innovative patterns - -Both approaches have their place in the BMAD v6 ecosystem, and this document serves as guidance for future module developers choosing their path. - ---- - -**Author:** BMAD-METHOD Development Team -**Contributors:** Claude Code AI Assistant -**License:** Same as BMAD-METHOD project diff --git a/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/KB_MODE_RESEARCH_FINDINGS.md b/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/KB_MODE_RESEARCH_FINDINGS.md deleted file mode 100644 index fa873d5a..00000000 --- a/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/KB_MODE_RESEARCH_FINDINGS.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,445 +0,0 @@ -# KB Mode Research Findings - -**Date:** 2025-10-01 18:25:00 EEST -**Research Goal:** Find interactive "how to use agents" mechanism from BMAD v4 -**Status:** ✅ FOUND - KB Mode exists in both main and feat/bmvcs-dev - ---- - -## Executive Summary - -**USER WAS RIGHT! ✅** - -BMAD-METHOD has a **KB Mode** (Knowledge Base Mode) that provides: - -- Interactive agent discovery -- "Knowledge base without overwhelming users with information upfront" -- Guided exploration of BMad capabilities -- Exactly what we need for Phase 3 documentation! - ---- - -## What is KB Mode? - -### Purpose (from kb-mode-interaction.md) - -> "Provide a user-friendly interface to the BMad knowledge base without overwhelming users with information upfront." - -### How It Works - -**Command:** `*kb-mode` - -**Flow:** - -1. User types `*kb-mode` -2. Agent enters KB mode -3. Presents 8 topic areas: - - Setup & Installation - - Workflows - - Web vs IDE - - **Agents** ← Critical for our needs! - - Documents - - Agile Process - - Configuration - - Best Practices - -4. User selects topic or asks question -5. Agent provides focused info from KB -6. Suggests related topics -7. Maintains conversational flow - -### Key Files - -**In both `main` and `feat/bmvcs-dev`:** - -1. **`.bmad-core/tasks/kb-mode-interaction.md`** (2.7k) - - Instructions for how to conduct KB mode - - Topic areas list - - Interaction patterns - -2. **`.bmad-core/data/bmad-kb.md`** (32k) - - Full knowledge base content - - Getting Started guide - - Agent descriptions - - Workflow explanations - - Best practices - -3. **`.bmad-core/agents/bmad-orchestrator.md`** - - Integrates KB mode - - Command: `*kb-mode` - - Behavior defined - ---- - -## KB Mode Topic Areas - -From `kb-mode-interaction.md`: - -```markdown -**What would you like to know more about?** - -1. **Setup & Installation** - Getting started with BMad -2. **Workflows** - Choosing the right workflow for your project -3. **Web vs IDE** - When to use each environment -4. **Agents** - Understanding specialized agents and their roles ← THIS! -5. **Documents** - PRDs, Architecture, Stories, and more -6. **Documents** - PRDs, Architecture, Stories, and more -7. **Configuration** - Customizing BMad for your needs -8. **Best Practices** - Tips for effective BMad usage -``` - -**Topic #4: Agents** is exactly what we need! - ---- - -## BMad Knowledge Base Content - -From `bmad-kb.md` (32k file): - -### Covers: - -- ✅ Overview of BMAD-METHOD -- ✅ How BMad Works (Core Method) -- ✅ The Two-Phase Approach (Planning vs Development) -- ✅ Development Loop -- ✅ Getting Started (Web UI & IDE) -- ✅ Agent descriptions and roles -- ✅ Workflow guidance -- ✅ Best practices - -### Key Sections for BMVCS Integration: - -**From bmad-kb.md:** - -```markdown -## How BMad Works - -### The Core Method - -BMad transforms you into a "Vibe CEO" - directing a team of specialized AI agents through structured workflows. Here's how: - -1. **You Direct, AI Executes**: You provide vision and decisions; agents handle implementation details -2. **Specialized Agents**: Each agent masters one role (PM, Developer, Architect, etc.) -3. **Structured Workflows**: Proven patterns guide you from idea to deployed code -4. **Clean Handoffs**: Fresh context windows ensure agents stay focused and effective -``` - ---- - -## Integration with Orchestrator - -From `.bmad-core/agents/bmad-orchestrator.md`: - -```yaml -commands: - kb-mode: Load full BMad knowledge base - -kb-mode-behavior: - - When *kb-mode is invoked, use kb-mode-interaction task - - Don't dump all KB content immediately - - Present topic areas and wait for user selection - - Provide focused, contextual responses -``` - -**Flow:** - -1. User types `*kb-mode` -2. Orchestrator loads `kb-mode-interaction.md` (instructions) -3. Orchestrator loads `bmad-kb.md` (knowledge base) -4. Presents topic menu -5. Answers questions from KB - ---- - -## Comparison: v4 vs v6 - -**v4 Name:** KB Mode (Knowledge Base Mode) -**v6 Status:** ✅ **STILL EXISTS** - Same name, same concept! - -**Evolution:** - -- Core concept preserved -- Now integrated with Orchestrator agent -- More structured topic areas -- Better separation (task + data) - -**Not removed, but enhanced!** - ---- - -## BMVCS Integration Opportunity - -### Current State - -**KB Mode has "Agents" topic (#4)** but: - -- ❌ No VCS workflow awareness -- ❌ No mention of VCS Adapter -- ❌ No BMVCS-specific guidance - -### What We Need to Add - -**Update `bmad-kb.md` section on Agents:** - -Add BMVCS-aware guidance: - -```markdown -## Agents - -### VCS-Aware Agents (with BMVCS) - -If you have BMVCS installed, these agents adapt to your VCS workflow: - -**Architect Agent** - Creates architecture documentation - -- GitHub Flow: Lightweight docs focusing on PRs -- GitFlow: Version-oriented with release cycles -- Trunk-Based: Flag-gated incremental docs - -**PM Agent** - Creates PRDs and requirements - -- GitHub Flow: Feature-scoped PRDs, 1-3 day stories -- GitFlow: Release-scoped PRDs, 3-5 day stories -- Trunk-Based: Flag-gated increments, <1 day stories - -**Dev Agent** - Implements features - -- GitHub Flow: Atomic commits with conventional style -- GitFlow: Descriptive commits with branch prefixes -- Trunk-Based: Feature-flag wrapped changes - -To use VCS-aware agents: - -1. Run `*discover` to detect your workflow -2. Agents automatically adapt to your VCS config -3. Templates adjust based on workflow type -``` - -### New KB Mode Topic - -Could add 9th topic: - -```markdown -9. **VCS Integration** - How BMVCS adapts to your workflow -``` - -Or expand existing topic #2: - -```markdown -2. **Workflows & VCS** - Choosing the right workflow and VCS integration -``` - ---- - -## Implications for Phase 3 - -### Phase 3.1: User Documentation - -**GOOD NEWS:** - -- ✅ Don't need to create "agent discovery" mechanism - it exists! -- ✅ KB Mode is the official way to learn about agents -- ✅ Just need to UPDATE kb mode with BMVCS info - -**What to Document:** - -1. **Update bmad-kb.md** (expand existing content) - - Add BMVCS section - - Add VCS-aware agent explanations - - Add workflow-specific adaptations - -2. **Create BMM_INTEGRATION_GUIDE.md** (new file) - - How to use VCS Adapter - - How BMM agents integrate - - Examples per workflow - - Troubleshooting - -3. **Update kb-mode-interaction.md** (optional) - - Add BMVCS/VCS topic area - - Or expand Workflows topic - -### Phase 3.2: Developer Documentation - -**Explain:** - -- How BMVCS extends KB Mode -- How agents check VCS config -- Template adaptation mechanism - ---- - -## Answers to Research Questions - -### Q: Does BMAD v6 have interactive guide mechanism? - -**A:** ✅ YES - KB Mode (`*kb-mode`) - -### Q: Was it in v4? - -**A:** ✅ YES - Same name, evolved in v6 - -### Q: How does it work? - -**A:** - -- Command-triggered (`*kb-mode`) -- Topic-based navigation -- Interactive Q&A -- References full KB (`bmad-kb.md`) - -### Q: Do we need to create new mechanism? - -**A:** ❌ NO - Extend existing KB Mode! - -### Q: Where does BMVCS fit? - -**A:** - -- Enhance KB content with VCS awareness -- Add to "Agents" topic -- Optional: new "VCS Integration" topic -- Update workflow guidance - ---- - -## Path Fix Dependency Re-Assessment - -### Original Question: - -"Do we need path fix before Phase 3?" - -### NEW ANSWER (after finding KB Mode): - -**Phase 3.1 can START NOW!** - -**Why:** - -- Phase 3.1 is about PLANNING documentation -- KB Mode research is documentation research -- Can design BMVCS KB additions without working integration -- Path fix enables TESTING examples, not designing them - -**Revised Approach:** - -**Session 3: Phase 3.1 Planning** (NOW - no path fix needed) - -1. ✅ Research KB Mode (DONE!) -2. Design BMVCS additions to bmad-kb.md -3. Plan BMM_INTEGRATION_GUIDE structure -4. Design examples (document what they SHOULD do) -5. Create Phase 3 implementation plan - -**Session 4: Path Fix** (before implementation) - -- Fix 3 agent files -- Now examples will work - -**Session 5+: Phase 3.1 Implementation** - -- Write BMVCS KB additions -- Create integration guide -- Test with working examples - -**Conclusion:** Path fix can wait! Planning first! ✅ - ---- - -## Recommended Next Steps - -### Immediate (Session 3 - Current) - -1. **Design BMVCS KB Content** - - What to add to bmad-kb.md "Agents" section - - How to explain VCS-aware adaptations - - Which examples to include - -2. **Plan BMM Integration Guide** - - Structure and sections - - Prerequisites - - Step-by-step workflows - - Troubleshooting - -3. **Update Phase 3 Plan** - - Based on KB Mode discovery - - Revise deliverables - - Adjust timeline - -### Next Session (Session 4) - -4. **Execute Path Fix** - - Fix 3 agent files in BMAD-METHOD - - Test integration - - Remove workarounds - -### Following Sessions (5+) - -5. **Implement Phase 3.1** - - Update bmad-kb.md - - Create BMM_INTEGRATION_GUIDE.md - - Test all examples - - Verify KB Mode works with BMVCS - ---- - -## Key Findings Summary - -✅ **KB Mode exists** - interactive agent discovery mechanism -✅ **Same as v4** - evolved but core concept preserved -✅ **Well-structured** - task instructions + knowledge base data -✅ **Extensible** - easy to add BMVCS content -✅ **Official pattern** - use KB Mode, don't reinvent - -❌ **Currently missing** - BMVCS/VCS awareness in KB -❌ **Path issue blocks** - testing examples, not planning - -📋 **Plan update** - Phase 3.1 can start NOW (planning) -🔧 **Path fix** - needed before implementation, not planning - ---- - -## Files for Reference - -**In BMAD-METHOD (both main and feat/bmvcs-dev):** - -``` -.bmad-core/ -├── tasks/ -│ └── kb-mode-interaction.md # How to run KB mode -├── data/ -│ └── bmad-kb.md # Knowledge base content (32k) -└── agents/ - └── bmad-orchestrator.md # Integrates *kb-mode command -``` - -**Created in Research:** - -``` -/tmp/ -├── PHASE_3_RESEARCH_PLAN.md # Original research plan -└── KB_MODE_RESEARCH_FINDINGS.md # This file -``` - ---- - -## Conclusion - -**User's intuition was spot-on!** 🎯 - -BMAD v4's interactive guide mechanism (KB Mode) not only exists in v6, but is well-maintained and ready to extend with BMVCS content. - -**Phase 3 Strategy:** - -1. Don't create new mechanism -2. Enhance existing KB Mode -3. Add BMVCS awareness to bmad-kb.md -4. Create complementary BMM_INTEGRATION_GUIDE.md -5. Leverage official pattern - -**"Fail to plan - plan to fail"** - This research validates the plan before execution! ✅ - ---- - -**Research Complete:** 2025-10-01 18:25:00 EEST -**Time Spent:** ~15 minutes -**Value:** Prevented redundant work, found official pattern -**Next:** Design BMVCS KB additions (Session 3 continues) diff --git a/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/TODO.md b/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/TODO.md deleted file mode 100644 index 68ed7fbd..00000000 --- a/src/modules/bmvcs/docs/TODO.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,230 +0,0 @@ -# BMVCS Module - TODO List - -**Last Updated:** 2025-10-01 -**Status:** Active Development -**Current Phase:** Phase 3 Planning - ---- - -## High Priority - -### Path Fix (Session 4) - -**Status:** Ready for execution -**Plan:** See `BMM_AGENTS_VCS_CONFIG_PATH_FIX.md` - -- [ ] Fix path in `src/modules/bmm/agents/architect.md` (line 68) -- [ ] Fix path in `src/modules/bmm/agents/pm.md` (line 68) -- [ ] Fix path in `src/modules/bmm/agents/dev.md` (line 73) -- [ ] Change: `bmad-core/vcs-config.yaml` → `.bmad/vcs-config.yaml` -- [ ] Test integration without workaround in test-bmvcs-install -- [ ] Remove workaround directory (`bmad-core/`) from test repo -- [ ] Verify all BMM agents work seamlessly - -**Estimated Time:** 15-25 minutes - ---- - -## Phase 3: Documentation & Quality - -### 3.1 User Documentation (In Progress) - -**Research Complete:** ✅ KB Mode found and analyzed - -#### KB Mode Extension - -- [ ] Design BMVCS additions to `.bmad-core/data/bmad-kb.md` -- [ ] Add "VCS-Aware Agents" section to KB -- [ ] Update "Agents" topic (#4) with VCS examples -- [ ] Add workflow-specific adaptation explanations -- [ ] Test KB Mode with BMVCS content - -**Reference:** `KB_MODE_RESEARCH_FINDINGS.md` - -#### BMM Integration Guide - -- [ ] Create `BMM_INTEGRATION_GUIDE.md` in appropriate location -- [ ] Document VCS Adapter usage -- [ ] Add BMM + BMVCS integration patterns -- [ ] Include examples per workflow (GitHub Flow, GitFlow, Trunk-Based) -- [ ] Add troubleshooting section - -#### Quick Start & Troubleshooting - -- [ ] Create `QUICK_START.md` for BMVCS -- [ ] Create `TROUBLESHOOTING.md` with common issues -- [ ] Add real project examples -- [ ] Create video/GIF demos (optional) - -**Estimated Time:** 2-3 hours total - ---- - -### 3.2 Developer Documentation - -- [ ] Document VCS Adapter Agent architecture -- [ ] Explain template adaptation mechanism -- [ ] Detail confidence scoring algorithm (if not already in VCS_DETECTION_CONFIDENCE.md) -- [ ] Add contribution guidelines for BMVCS -- [ ] Document template development guide -- [ ] Add API/interface contracts - -**Deliverables:** - -- `ARCHITECTURE.md` (or expand existing docs) -- `TEMPLATE_GUIDE.md` -- `CONTRIBUTING.md` - -**Estimated Time:** 2 hours - ---- - -### 3.3 API Documentation - -- [ ] Document `vcs-config.yaml` schema formally -- [ ] Document template YAML schema -- [ ] Add inline JSDoc comments to code -- [ ] Create schema validation files -- [ ] Generate API reference - -**Deliverables:** - -- `schemas/vcs-config.schema.json` -- `schemas/template.schema.json` -- `API_REFERENCE.md` - -**Estimated Time:** 2 hours - ---- - -### 3.4 Automated Testing - -- [ ] Create test suite for each workflow -- [ ] Add YAML validation tests -- [ ] Create template loading tests -- [ ] Add integration tests with mock BMM agents -- [ ] Performance benchmarks -- [ ] CI/CD pipeline setup - -**Deliverables:** - -- `tests/workflows/` - Workflow tests -- `tests/templates/` - Template tests -- `tests/integration/` - Integration tests -- `.github/workflows/test-bmvcs.yml` - CI pipeline - -**Estimated Time:** 3-4 hours - ---- - -### 3.5 Performance Optimization - -- [ ] Profile template loading -- [ ] Optimize large document adaptation -- [ ] Cache configuration when possible -- [ ] Test with repos >100K files -- [ ] Benchmark all operations -- [ ] Document performance characteristics - -**Target Metrics:** - -- Discovery: < 2 seconds -- Validation: < 1 second -- Adaptation: < 5 seconds for large docs -- Config load: < 100ms - -**Estimated Time:** 2-3 hours - ---- - -## Documentation Standards (Future) - -### Naming Conventions - -- [ ] Review and apply `SESSION_END_PROTOCOL.md` naming if applicable -- [ ] Apply `DOCUMENTATION_CONVENTIONS.md` sequential numbering (01-99) if needed -- [ ] Standardize document naming across module -- [ ] Ensure consistency with BMAD v6 module standards - -### README Updates - -- [ ] Update `src/modules/bmvcs/docs/README.md` with new documents -- [ ] Add links to research findings -- [ ] Add links to TODO (this file) -- [ ] Organize by category (Principles, Research, Plans, Guides) - -### Metadata - -- [ ] Add creation dates to all docs -- [ ] Add "Last Updated" timestamps -- [ ] Add version numbers where appropriate -- [ ] Add status indicators (Draft, Review, Final) - ---- - -## Future Enhancements (Post-Phase 3) - -### SM/TEA Agent Integration (Optional) - -- [ ] Evaluate if SM agent needs VCS awareness -- [ ] Evaluate if TEA agent needs VCS awareness -- [ ] Document decision and rationale - -**Context:** Currently 3/5 BMM agents have VCS integration (Architect, PM, Dev). SM and TEA don't have it by design. - -### Additional VCS Support - -- [ ] SVN workflow templates -- [ ] Perforce workflow templates -- [ ] Mercurial workflow templates -- [ ] Custom workflow enhancement - -### Advanced Features - -- [ ] Auto-detection enhancement -- [ ] Migration guides between workflows -- [ ] Team collaboration patterns -- [ ] Multi-repo scenarios - ---- - -## Completed Tasks - -### Phase 2: Alpha Testing ✅ - -- [x] Core BMVCS functionality tested -- [x] VCS Adapter Agent tested (sections 2.1-2.5) -- [x] BMM integration tested (sections 2.6-2.9) -- [x] Path inconsistency discovered and documented -- [x] Workaround created for immediate use -- [x] All test results documented in `~/test-bmvcs-install/testing/` - -### Research & Planning ✅ - -- [x] KB Mode research completed (KB_MODE_RESEARCH_FINDINGS.md) -- [x] Path fix plan created (BMM_AGENTS_VCS_CONFIG_PATH_FIX.md) -- [x] Phase 3 strategy defined -- [x] Documentation structure organized - ---- - -## Notes - -- **Test Repository:** `~/test-bmvcs-install/` contains all alpha test results -- **Session Documentation:** See `SESSION_END_*.md` files in test repo -- **Branch:** All work on `feat/bmvcs-dev` -- **Integration:** Path fix required before Phase 3.1 implementation (but not planning) - ---- - -**Priority Order for Next Sessions:** - -1. **Session 4:** Execute path fix (enables testing) -2. **Session 5+:** Implement Phase 3.1 (user documentation) -3. **Later:** Phase 3.2-3.5 (developer docs, testing, performance) - ---- - -**Generated:** 2025-10-01 18:45:00 EEST -**Module:** BMVCS (BMAD VCS Adapter) -**Status:** Phase 3 Planning → Ready for Session 4