From bf2ad272fd27fcf5fc282c2605174b7f591b6ba7 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Serhii Date: Wed, 1 Oct 2025 05:58:49 +0300 Subject: [PATCH] docs(bmvcs): add alpha testing plan and session roadmap MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit - Add comprehensive testing checklist for VCS Discovery Flow - Document installer testing requirements - Define success metrics (MVP, Target, Stretch) - Add integration testing with BMM module - Include documentation validation tasks 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code) Co-Authored-By: Claude --- src/modules/bmvcs/NEXT_SESSION.md | 375 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 1 file changed, 375 insertions(+) create mode 100644 src/modules/bmvcs/NEXT_SESSION.md diff --git a/src/modules/bmvcs/NEXT_SESSION.md b/src/modules/bmvcs/NEXT_SESSION.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..4166bbf7 --- /dev/null +++ b/src/modules/bmvcs/NEXT_SESSION.md @@ -0,0 +1,375 @@ +# BMVCS: Next Session Plan + +**Generated:** 2025-09-30 +**Current Status:** Alpha Development - Documentation Phase Complete +**Branch:** feat/bmvcs-dev + +--- + +## 🎯 Session Overview + +Focus: Testing, Validation, and Production Readiness + +--- + +## 📋 Priority Tasks + +### High Priority (Must Do) + +#### 1. Testing & Validation + +**Test VCS Discovery Flow** + +- [ ] Test `discover-vcs` task with real Git repositories +- [ ] Test with GitHub Flow detection +- [ ] Test with GitFlow detection +- [ ] Test with Trunk-Based Development detection +- [ ] Test with no VCS scenario +- [ ] Validate `.bmad/vcs-config.yaml` generation + +**Test VCS Adapter Agent** + +- [ ] Activate vcs-adapter agent in Claude Code +- [ ] Test `*discover` command +- [ ] Test `*adapt-doc` command with sample document +- [ ] Test `*show-config` command +- [ ] Test `*validate` command +- [ ] Verify error handling and user prompts + +**Test Adaptation Templates** + +- [ ] Load and validate all 5 YAML templates +- [ ] Test template application to documents +- [ ] Verify terminology substitutions work +- [ ] Verify workflow adaptations apply correctly + +#### 2. Installer Testing + +**Module Installation** + +- [ ] Test `_module-installer/installer.js` logic +- [ ] Verify `install-menu-config.yaml` configuration +- [ ] Test installation to target project +- [ ] Verify directory structure creation +- [ ] Test file copying and permissions + +**Integration Testing** + +- [ ] Test BMVCS installation alongside BMM module +- [ ] Verify optional dependency behavior +- [ ] Test BMM agents with BMVCS integration +- [ ] Validate graceful degradation when BMVCS not installed + +#### 3. Documentation Validation + +**Review and Update** + +- [ ] Test all internal documentation links +- [ ] Verify code examples are executable +- [ ] Review VCS_AGNOSTIC_PROPOSAL for accuracy +- [ ] Update examples with real test results +- [ ] Add screenshots/outputs to examples + +--- + +### Medium Priority (Should Do) + +#### 4. Workflow Implementation + +**setup-vcs Workflow** + +- [ ] Review workflow.yaml structure +- [ ] Implement complete workflow steps +- [ ] Test workflow execution end-to-end +- [ ] Add workflow to agent commands +- [ ] Document workflow usage + +**Workflow Templates** + +- [ ] Create checklist.md for setup-vcs +- [ ] Add template.md if needed +- [ ] Test workflow invocation from agent + +#### 5. BMM Integration + +**Agent Integration Hooks** + +- [ ] Test Architect Agent + BMVCS integration +- [ ] Test PM Agent + BMVCS integration +- [ ] Test Dev Agent + BMVCS integration +- [ ] Document integration patterns +- [ ] Create integration examples + +**Optional Dependency Pattern** + +- [ ] Verify BMM works without BMVCS +- [ ] Verify BMVCS enhances BMM when present +- [ ] Document detection mechanism +- [ ] Test graceful fallback behavior + +#### 6. Edge Cases & Error Handling + +**Error Scenarios** + +- [ ] Test invalid VCS configuration +- [ ] Test missing .git directory +- [ ] Test corrupted vcs-config.yaml +- [ ] Test adaptation with missing template +- [ ] Verify all error messages are helpful + +**Boundary Conditions** + +- [ ] Test with very large repositories +- [ ] Test with nested .git directories +- [ ] Test with git submodules +- [ ] Test in monorepo scenarios + +--- + +### Low Priority (Nice to Have) + +#### 7. Advanced Features + +**Confidence Scoring Refinement** + +- [ ] Validate scoring algorithm accuracy +- [ ] Add more detection heuristics +- [ ] Test ambiguous scenarios +- [ ] Document scoring methodology updates + +**Additional VCS Support** + +- [ ] Add SVN detection implementation +- [ ] Add Perforce detection implementation +- [ ] Add Mercurial detection implementation +- [ ] Create templates for non-Git VCS + +**Custom Workflow Support** + +- [ ] Test custom VCS workflow definition +- [ ] Validate custom template creation +- [ ] Document custom workflow guide +- [ ] Add custom workflow examples + +#### 8. Developer Experience + +**CLI Enhancements** + +- [ ] Consider adding CLI commands for BMVCS +- [ ] Add quick setup command +- [ ] Add validation command +- [ ] Improve output formatting + +**Configuration UI** + +- [ ] Consider interactive config editor +- [ ] Add config validation on save +- [ ] Implement config presets +- [ ] Add config export/import + +--- + +## 🔧 Technical Debt + +### Code Quality + +- [ ] Add JSDoc comments to installer.js +- [ ] Validate all YAML files against schema +- [ ] Review task markdown structure +- [ ] Check for TODO/FIXME comments + +### Standards Compliance + +- [ ] Run against BMB validation (if available) +- [ ] Compare with other v6 modules +- [ ] Verify naming conventions +- [ ] Check file structure completeness + +### Performance + +- [ ] Test discovery with large repos (>100K files) +- [ ] Profile adaptation speed +- [ ] Optimize template loading +- [ ] Cache configuration when possible + +--- + +## 📝 Documentation Tasks + +### User Documentation + +- [ ] Write Quick Start guide with real examples +- [ ] Add troubleshooting section to README +- [ ] Create video/GIF demos (optional) +- [ ] Write migration guide from v5 + +### Developer Documentation + +- [ ] Document adapter agent architecture +- [ ] Explain confidence scoring algorithm +- [ ] Detail template structure +- [ ] Add contribution guidelines specific to BMVCS + +### API Documentation + +- [ ] Document vcs-config.yaml schema +- [ ] Document template YAML schema +- [ ] Document installer API +- [ ] Add inline code documentation + +--- + +## 🚀 Release Preparation + +### Pre-Alpha Checklist + +- [ ] All high-priority tests pass +- [ ] Documentation links work +- [ ] Examples are verified +- [ ] Known issues documented +- [ ] CHANGELOG.md created + +### Alpha Release Checklist + +- [ ] Module installs successfully +- [ ] Core workflows functional +- [ ] Integration with BMM tested +- [ ] README is complete +- [ ] Version tagged in git + +### Beta Release Preparation + +- [ ] User feedback incorporated +- [ ] Edge cases handled +- [ ] Performance optimized +- [ ] Full test coverage +- [ ] Production-ready installer + +--- + +## 🎯 Success Metrics + +**Definition of Done for Next Session:** + +✅ **Minimum (MVP):** + +- VCS discovery works for Git GitHub Flow +- vcs-adapter agent commands functional +- Module installs without errors +- Basic documentation verified + +✅ **Target (Good):** + +- All 3 Git workflows detected correctly +- All agent commands tested +- Integration with BMM validated +- All documentation complete + +✅ **Stretch (Excellent):** + +- No VCS scenario works +- Custom workflow support functional +- Full test suite passes +- Ready for alpha release + +--- + +## 📊 Current State Summary + +### ✅ Completed + +- Module structure (agents, tasks, templates, workflows) +- Core documentation (README, principles, proposal, confidence) +- Development approach analysis +- 5 VCS adaptation templates +- Installer configuration +- Examples folder with implementations + +### 🚧 In Progress + +- Testing and validation +- Workflow implementation +- BMM integration + +### ⏳ Not Started + +- Production testing +- User feedback collection +- Performance optimization +- Advanced VCS support (non-Git) + +--- + +## 🔗 Quick Links + +**Key Files to Review:** + +- `agents/vcs-adapter.md` - Agent implementation +- `tasks/discover-vcs.md` - Discovery logic +- `tasks/create-vcs-adapted-doc.md` - Adaptation logic +- `_module-installer/installer.js` - Installation script +- `workflows/setup-vcs/` - Setup workflow + +**Documentation:** + +- `docs/VCS_AGNOSTIC_PROPOSAL.md` - Implementation spec +- `docs/DEVELOPMENT_APPROACH.md` - Module creation analysis +- `examples/vcs-adaptation-examples.md` - Usage examples + +**Testing Targets:** + +- `.bmad/vcs-config.yaml` - Configuration output +- `templates/vcs-adaptations/*.yaml` - Adaptation rules + +--- + +## 💡 Ideas for Exploration + +### Research Topics + +- GitHub CLI integration for workflow detection +- Automatic PR template adaptation +- CI/CD configuration detection +- Branch protection rule detection + +### Innovation Opportunities + +- AI-powered workflow recommendation +- Team workflow analytics +- VCS migration assistant +- Workflow compliance checker + +### Community Features + +- Shared custom workflow library +- Team workflow templates +- VCS best practices database +- Workflow pattern catalog + +--- + +## 🤝 Questions to Resolve + +1. Should BMVCS have its own CLI or only work through agents? +2. How to handle VCS workflow changes mid-project? +3. Should we auto-detect workflow or always ask user? +4. What's the upgrade path from alpha to beta? +5. How to collect user feedback during alpha? + +--- + +## 🎓 Learning Goals + +By end of next session, understand: + +- How BMVCS integrates with real Claude Code workflows +- What pain points exist in VCS detection +- How users interact with adapter agent +- What edge cases need addressing +- Whether confidence scoring is accurate + +--- + +**Remember:** Focus on making BMVCS **useful** before making it **perfect**. Alpha is about validation, not completion. + +Start next session with: **Test VCS Discovery Flow** 🚀