diff --git a/bmad-enhancements/progress-tracker.md b/bmad-enhancements/progress-tracker.md index d0334416..6cb4b5e1 100644 --- a/bmad-enhancements/progress-tracker.md +++ b/bmad-enhancements/progress-tracker.md @@ -5,14 +5,71 @@ **Project**: BMAD Context Engineering Enhancement **Start Date**: January 2025 **Target Completion**: January 2025 (12 days) -**Current Phase**: πŸ“‹ Planning βœ… Complete β†’ πŸ—οΈ Phase 1 Foundation βœ… Complete β†’ πŸš€ Phase 2 Agent Enhancement βœ… COMPLETE β†’ 🎯 Phase 3 Rich Context (Ready) -**Overall Progress**: 85% (Phase 1 βœ… + Phase 2 βœ… COMPLETE) +**Current Phase**: πŸ“‹ Planning βœ… Complete β†’ πŸ—οΈ Phase 1 Foundation βœ… Complete β†’ πŸš€ Phase 2 Agent Enhancement βœ… COMPLETE β†’ πŸ“š Phase 2.5 Documentation & Validation (Ready) +**Overall Progress**: 80% (Phase 1 βœ… + Phase 2 βœ… + Phase 2.5 Documentation & Validation Required) **Codebase Analysis**: βœ… Complete - Foundation + All Agent Enhancements Implemented +**Next Priority**: 🎯 Phase 2.5 Documentation & Validation for actionable guidance and quantified improvements --- ## πŸš€ IMMEDIATE NEXT ACTIONS (Ready to Execute) +### πŸ”₯ **Phase 2.5.1: Project Documentation Update** (Ready Now) + +**Priority**: HIGH ⚑ +**Estimated Time**: 45 minutes +**Dependencies**: Phase 2 Complete βœ… +**Purpose**: Provide actionable instructions for users to leverage new context capabilities + +#### Ready-to-Execute Documentation Tasks: + +1. **[ ] Update main README.md** βœ… READY + + - Add Context Engineering section with new capabilities overview + - Create quick-start guide for enhanced agents + - Include practical context handoff workflow examples + +2. **[ ] Update bmad-workflow-guide.md** βœ… READY + + - Add "Context-Aware Workflows" section + - Document decision guide: when to use each context tool + - Provide multi-agent context transfer examples + +3. **[ ] Create context-engineering-guide.md** βœ… READY + - Comprehensive tutorial for all context features + - Real-world scenario examples with templates + - Troubleshooting guide for common issues + +### πŸ”₯ **Phase 2.5.2: Performance Benchmarking** (Ready Now) + +**Priority**: HIGH ⚑ +**Estimated Time**: 60 minutes +**Dependencies**: Phase 2 Complete βœ… +**Purpose**: Quantify improvements and validate effectiveness with data + +#### Ready-to-Execute Benchmarking Tasks: + +1. **[ ] Create benchmark framework** βœ… READY + + - Define 5 standard test workflows + - Establish measurement criteria and baselines + - Create standardized comparison methodology + +2. **[ ] Execute performance comparisons** βœ… READY + + - Dev Agent: Token efficiency and speed metrics + - Planning Agents: Context quality and handoff success rates + - Templates: Effectiveness vs ad-hoc approaches + +3. **[ ] Analyze and report results** βœ… READY + - Document quantitative improvements achieved + - Identify optimization opportunities + - Provide data-driven Phase 3 recommendations + +--- + +## πŸ“‹ COMPLETED ACTIONS + ### πŸ”₯ **Phase 2.2: Master Orchestrator Enhancement** βœ… COMPLETE **Priority**: HIGH ⚑ @@ -405,6 +462,136 @@ --- +## πŸ“‹ Phase 2.5: Documentation & Validation (Post-Implementation) - Status: πŸ”„ Ready + +### 2.5.1 Project Documentation Update + +**Priority**: HIGH ⚑ +**Estimated Time**: 45 minutes +**Dependencies**: Phase 2 Complete βœ… +**Purpose**: Provide actionable guidance for leveraging new context capabilities + +#### Documentation Tasks: + +**[ ] Update main README.md** + +- [ ] Add Context Engineering section highlighting new capabilities +- [ ] Provide quick-start guide for using enhanced agents +- [ ] Include examples of context handoff workflows +- [ ] Document the 5 new context dependencies available to all agents + +**[ ] Update bmad-workflow-guide.md** + +- [ ] Add section on "Context-Aware Workflows" +- [ ] Document when to use context-optimization vs context-handoff +- [ ] Provide examples of multi-agent context transfers +- [ ] Include best practices for context management + +**[ ] Create context-engineering-guide.md** + +- [ ] Comprehensive guide to new context features +- [ ] Step-by-step tutorials for each context capability +- [ ] Template usage examples with real scenarios +- [ ] Troubleshooting common context issues + +**[ ] Update agent documentation** + +- [ ] Update individual agent docs to highlight context capabilities +- [ ] Add "Context Management" section to each agent's whenToUse +- [ ] Document context-specific commands and workflows +- [ ] Include context handoff examples between agent pairs + +**Phase 2.5.1 Completion**: ⏸️ 0% - Ready to Execute + +### 2.5.2 Performance Benchmarking & Validation + +**Priority**: HIGH ⚑ +**Estimated Time**: 60 minutes +**Dependencies**: Phase 2 Complete βœ… +**Purpose**: Quantify improvements and validate effectiveness of context enhancements + +#### Benchmarking Tasks: + +**[ ] Create benchmark test scenarios** + +- [ ] Define 5 standard workflows (simple to complex) +- [ ] Create test cases for each agent type (dev vs planning) +- [ ] Document baseline performance metrics from old agents +- [ ] Establish measurement criteria (time, accuracy, context retention) + +**[ ] Performance Testing Framework** + +- [ ] Create benchmark-test.md with standardized test procedures +- [ ] Define metrics: context assembly time, token efficiency, handoff success rate +- [ ] Set up before/after comparison methodology +- [ ] Include qualitative assessment criteria (clarity, completeness, usability) + +**[ ] Execute Agent Performance Comparisons** + +- [ ] **Dev Agent Benchmarking**: Lean context vs original + + - Token usage comparison (target: <2000 vs baseline) + - Context assembly speed (target: <1 second) + - Code relevance assessment (target: >95%) + - Task completion accuracy + +- [ ] **Planning Agent Benchmarking**: Enhanced vs original + + - Context comprehensiveness (target: >90% coverage) + - Cross-agent handoff success (target: 98% success rate) + - Context quality scoring (target: >4.0/5.0) + - User satisfaction metrics + +- [ ] **Template Effectiveness Testing**: New templates vs ad-hoc + - Context handoff completion time + - Information retention accuracy + - Error reduction in transfers + - User adoption rate + +**[ ] Results Analysis & Reporting** + +- [ ] Create performance-benchmark-results.md +- [ ] Document quantitative improvements achieved +- [ ] Identify areas for further optimization +- [ ] Provide data-driven recommendations for Phase 3 +- [ ] Include ROI analysis of context engineering effort + +**[ ] Validation Testing** + +- [ ] Test backward compatibility (ensure no regressions) +- [ ] Validate context capabilities work across agent teams +- [ ] Test template loading and processing +- [ ] Verify configuration changes don't break existing workflows + +**Phase 2.5.2 Completion**: ⏸️ 0% - Ready to Execute + +**πŸ“Š Phase 2.5 Overall Progress: 0% - Ready for Implementation** + +#### Expected Deliverables: + +**Documentation Outputs:** + +- Updated README.md with Context Engineering quick-start guide +- Enhanced bmad-workflow-guide.md with context-aware workflows +- New context-engineering-guide.md comprehensive tutorial +- Updated agent documentation with context management sections + +**Benchmarking Outputs:** + +- benchmark-test.md with standardized testing procedures +- performance-benchmark-results.md with quantified improvements +- Baseline vs enhanced agent performance metrics +- ROI analysis and data-driven Phase 3 recommendations + +**Benefits:** + +- βœ… Actionable user guidance for leveraging new features +- βœ… Quantified proof of enhancement effectiveness +- βœ… Data-driven insights for future optimization +- βœ… User adoption acceleration through clear documentation + +--- + ## πŸ“‹ Phase 3: Rich Context Features (Days 10-12) - Status: πŸ”„ Planned ### 3.1 Rich Context Tasks (Planning Agents Only)