diff --git a/1-4b.story.md b/1-4b.story.md deleted file mode 100644 index 8abe9fef..00000000 --- a/1-4b.story.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,208 +0,0 @@ -# Story 1.4b: Authentication Integration Testing - -## Status -Ready - -## Story -**As a** development team, -**I want** to validate the authentication implementation with comprehensive integration testing, -**so that** we have confidence the authentication system works end-to-end in all scenarios. - -## Dependencies -- Story 1.4: Basic Authentication Setup (Complete) - -## Acceptance Criteria -1. Keycloak realm and clients are automatically configured without manual intervention -2. Complete authentication flow works from Blazor UI through Keycloak to API -3. JWT tokens are properly validated by the API endpoints -4. Logout functionality clears sessions and redirects correctly -5. All authentication scenarios are tested and documented - -## Tasks / Subtasks - -- [ ] Task 1: Fix Keycloak Realm Import Automation - - [ ] Debug realm import failure issues - - [ ] Investigate missing client scope dependencies - - [ ] Fix "uma_authorization" role dependency - - [ ] Resolve client scope reference errors - - [ ] Update realm JSON configuration for reliable import - - [ ] Add missing default client scopes - - [ ] Fix role and scope dependencies - - [ ] Ensure proper realm initialization order - - [ ] Verify automatic realm import works on fresh deployment - - [ ] Document any manual steps still required - -- [ ] Task 2: Create Missing Environment Configuration - - [ ] Create `.env.example` file with all required variables - - [ ] Keycloak admin credentials - - [ ] Database connection settings - - [ ] Application URLs and ports - - [ ] Update docker-compose.yml to use environment file - - [ ] Document environment variable usage in README - -- [ ] Task 3: End-to-End Authentication Flow Testing - - [ ] Test complete login flow - - [ ] Access protected Blazor page - - [ ] Redirect to Keycloak login - - [ ] Authenticate with test user - - [ ] Redirect back to application - - [ ] Verify user context populated - - [ ] Test logout flow - - [ ] Logout from application - - [ ] Verify session cleared in Blazor - - [ ] Verify session cleared in Keycloak - - [ ] Confirm redirect to login page - - [ ] Test authentication state persistence - - [ ] Verify session survives page refresh - - [ ] Test session timeout behavior - - [ ] Validate token refresh if implemented - -- [ ] Task 4: API JWT Token Integration Testing - - [ ] Create test API endpoint requiring authentication - - [ ] Test authenticated API calls from Blazor - - [ ] Verify JWT token included in requests - - [ ] Confirm API validates token successfully - - [ ] Test API returns user context from token - - [ ] Test unauthenticated API access - - [ ] Verify protected endpoints return 401 - - [ ] Confirm health endpoints remain public - - [ ] Test token validation scenarios - - [ ] Valid token access - - [ ] Expired token handling - - [ ] Invalid token rejection - - [ ] Missing token handling - -- [ ] Task 5: Error Scenario Testing - - [ ] Test Keycloak unavailable scenarios - - [ ] Application behavior when Keycloak is down - - [ ] Error messages and fallback behavior - - [ ] Service recovery after Keycloak returns - - [ ] Test invalid configuration scenarios - - [ ] Wrong client ID configuration - - [ ] Invalid realm configuration - - [ ] Network connectivity issues - - [ ] Test edge cases - - [ ] Concurrent login attempts - - [ ] Multiple browser sessions - - [ ] Direct API access attempts - -- [ ] Task 6: Performance and Security Testing - - [ ] Test authentication performance - - [ ] Login flow response times - - [ ] Token validation performance - - [ ] Session management overhead - - [ ] Verify security configurations - - [ ] HTTPS enforcement in production config - - [ ] Secure cookie settings - - [ ] Token expiration handling - - [ ] Proper error message sanitization - - [ ] Test concurrent user scenarios - - [ ] Multiple simultaneous logins - - [ ] Concurrent API requests - - [ ] Session isolation between users - -- [ ] Task 7: Resolve Package Version Conflicts - - [ ] Analyze Microsoft.IdentityModel version conflicts - - [ ] Identify conflicting package versions - - [ ] Determine required version compatibility - - [ ] Update packages to consistent versions - - [ ] Test build after version resolution - - [ ] Verify no regression in functionality - - [ ] Update documentation with final package versions - -- [ ] Task 8: Create Automated Integration Tests - - [ ] Set up integration test project - - [ ] Create Docker test environment - - [ ] Implement automated authentication flow tests - - [ ] Login/logout automation - - [ ] JWT token validation tests - - [ ] API integration tests - - [ ] Configure CI/CD pipeline integration - - [ ] Document test execution procedures - -- [ ] Task 9: Production Readiness Validation - - [ ] Create production configuration templates - - [ ] Production appsettings.json examples - - [ ] Production docker-compose configuration - - [ ] Environment variable documentation - - [ ] Test production-like deployment - - [ ] HTTPS configuration - - [ ] External Keycloak integration - - [ ] Database connection validation - - [ ] Create deployment checklist - - [ ] Document monitoring and troubleshooting - -## Dev Notes - -### Issues Identified from Story 1.4 -1. **Keycloak Realm Import Failures** - ``` - ERROR: Unable to find composite realm role: uma_authorization - Referenced client scope 'roles' doesn't exist - Referenced client scope 'web-origins' doesn't exist - ``` - -2. **Missing Configuration Files** - - No `.env.example` file despite story mentioning environment variables - - Manual setup steps not documented - -3. **Package Version Conflicts** - - Multiple Microsoft.IdentityModel package version warnings - - Test project has version conflicts (6.35.0 vs 7.0.3) - -4. **Untested Integration Points** - - JWT token flow from Blazor to API never validated - - Logout functionality not tested end-to-end - - Error scenarios not covered - -### Testing Environment Requirements -- Clean Docker environment for reliable testing -- Test user accounts in Keycloak -- Isolated test database -- Network connectivity for container-to-container communication - -### Success Criteria -- All authentication flows work without manual intervention -- Automated tests validate critical scenarios -- Production deployment documentation complete -- No package version conflicts or build warnings -- Performance meets acceptable thresholds - -## Acceptance Testing -To verify successful completion: -1. Fresh `docker-compose up` starts all services successfully -2. Keycloak realm and clients are automatically configured -3. Login flow works: Blazor → Keycloak → back to Blazor with user context -4. API calls include JWT tokens and validate successfully -5. Logout clears all sessions and returns to login -6. Automated tests pass in CI/CD pipeline -7. Production deployment checklist complete - -## Security Considerations -- Validate all authentication flows for security best practices -- Ensure no sensitive information is logged -- Verify proper token expiration and refresh -- Confirm secure defaults for production deployment -- Test authentication bypass scenarios - -## Change Log -| Date | Version | Description | Author | -|------|---------|-------------|--------| -| 2025-01-21 | 1.0 | Created from Story 1.4 integration testing tasks | Dev Agent | - -## Dev Agent Record - -### Agent Model Used -_TBD_ - -### Debug Log References -_TBD_ - -### Completion Notes List -_TBD_ - -### File List -_TBD_ - -## QA Results -_TBD_ \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/1-4r.story.md b/1-4r.story.md deleted file mode 100644 index 5dcd7696..00000000 --- a/1-4r.story.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,198 +0,0 @@ -# Story 1.4-R: Authentication Configuration Remediation - -## Status -Ready - -## Story -**As a** developer, -**I want** the authentication system from Story 1.4 to be immediately usable without manual configuration, -**so that** I can start development work that depends on authentication without encountering setup blockers. - -## Dependencies -- Story 1.4: Basic Authentication Setup (Complete - Implementation) - -## Background -Story 1.4 successfully implemented the complete authentication system, but analysis revealed critical gaps that prevent immediate productive use: - -1. **Missing Docker configuration** prevents container startup -2. **Environment configuration gaps** require manual intervention -3. **Package version conflicts** create build warnings -4. **Missing documentation** for immediate development use - -This remediation focuses **only on critical blockers** that prevent the authentication system from being immediately usable for development. - -## Acceptance Criteria -1. `docker-compose up` starts all containers successfully on first try -2. Authentication system works without any manual configuration steps -3. No build warnings related to authentication packages -4. Clear setup documentation for new developers -5. All environment variables properly configured with working defaults - -## Tasks / Subtasks - -- [ ] Task 1: Fix Docker Container Configuration - - [ ] Create missing Dockerfiles - - [ ] API Dockerfile with proper multi-stage build - - [ ] Web Dockerfile with Blazor Server configuration - - [ ] Verify all COPY and build commands work correctly - - [ ] Fix docker-compose.yml container references - - [ ] Update build contexts to point to existing Dockerfiles - - [ ] Verify container networking configuration - - [ ] Test container health checks work properly - - [ ] Validate complete docker-compose startup - - [ ] `docker-compose up` succeeds without errors - - [ ] All services start and pass health checks - - [ ] Container-to-container communication works - -- [ ] Task 2: Resolve Package Version Conflicts - - [ ] Analyze Microsoft.IdentityModel package conflicts - - [ ] Identify conflicting versions (6.35.0 vs 7.0.3) - - [ ] Determine compatibility requirements - - [ ] Update to consistent version across all projects - - [ ] Test after version resolution - - [ ] Clean build succeeds without warnings - - [ ] All authentication functionality still works - - [ ] No runtime errors introduced - - [ ] Update project documentation with final versions - -- [ ] Task 3: Complete Environment Configuration - - [ ] Create comprehensive `.env.example` file - - [ ] All Keycloak configuration variables - - [ ] Database connection strings - - [ ] Application URLs and ports - - [ ] Security settings with safe defaults - - [ ] Update docker-compose.yml to use environment file - - [ ] Add env_file references where needed - - [ ] Remove hardcoded values - - [ ] Ensure consistent variable naming - - [ ] Create `.env` with working local development defaults - - [ ] Ready-to-use values for immediate startup - - [ ] Clear comments explaining each variable - - [ ] Safe defaults that work out-of-the-box - -- [ ] Task 4: Fix Keycloak Client Configuration - - [ ] Update realm JSON with working client configuration - - [ ] Fix client secret handling for omniwatchai-web client - - [ ] Ensure redirect URIs match local development setup - - [ ] Verify client scopes and roles are properly configured - - [ ] Test realm import functionality - - [ ] Verify `--import-realm` works without errors - - [ ] Confirm test users are created successfully - - [ ] Validate client configuration is applied correctly - - [ ] Document any remaining manual steps (if unavoidable) - -- [ ] Task 5: Create Quick Start Documentation - - [ ] Create `AUTHENTICATION.md` guide - - [ ] Step-by-step setup instructions - - [ ] Prerequisites and dependencies - - [ ] Troubleshooting common issues - - [ ] How to verify authentication is working - - [ ] Update main README.md with authentication section - - [ ] Link to detailed authentication guide - - [ ] Quick setup commands - - [ ] Development workflow integration - - [ ] Add inline code comments for complex authentication setup - - [ ] Program.cs authentication configuration - - [ ] Key configuration sections - - [ ] Integration points developers need to know - -- [ ] Task 6: Smoke Test Implementation - - [ ] Create minimal smoke test for authentication flow - - [ ] Verify Keycloak starts and accepts connections - - [ ] Test basic realm configuration is loaded - - [ ] Confirm API accepts JWT tokens - - [ ] Validate Web app can redirect to Keycloak - - [ ] Add smoke test to docker-compose - - [ ] Health check containers that validate authentication - - [ ] Clear pass/fail indicators in logs - - [ ] Automatic test execution on startup - - [ ] Document how to run smoke tests manually - -## Dev Notes - -### Critical Blockers Identified -Based on reality audit of Story 1.4, these items prevent immediate usability: - -1. **Docker Configuration Missing** - - docker-compose.yml references Dockerfiles that may not exist - - Container build failures prevent system startup - -2. **Environment Variables Incomplete** - - Story mentions `.env.example` but file doesn't exist - - Hardcoded values in docker-compose prevent customization - -3. **Package Conflicts** - - Microsoft.IdentityModel version warnings indicate potential runtime issues - - Build warnings reduce confidence in stability - -4. **Keycloak Import Issues** - - Realm import automation partially failing - - Requires specific client configuration for development use - -### Out of Scope -This remediation **explicitly excludes**: -- Comprehensive integration testing (Story 1.4b) -- Performance optimization -- Production deployment configuration -- Advanced security features -- New authentication features - -### Success Metrics -- [ ] New developer can run `git clone` → `docker-compose up` → working authentication -- [ ] Zero manual configuration steps required for basic development -- [ ] All build warnings resolved -- [ ] Clear documentation for next steps - -## Acceptance Testing -To verify successful remediation: -1. **Fresh Environment Test**: Clone repository on clean machine -2. **One-Command Startup**: `docker-compose up` succeeds completely -3. **Authentication Works**: Can access protected pages through Keycloak -4. **No Manual Steps**: No additional configuration required -5. **Clean Build**: No warnings or errors in build output - -## Technical Requirements -- All containers start successfully -- Keycloak realm imports automatically -- JWT authentication validates correctly -- Blazor authentication redirects work -- Health endpoints respond properly -- No package version conflicts - -## Time Estimate -**1-2 days** focused remediation work - -### Task Breakdown -- Task 1 (Docker): 4-6 hours -- Task 2 (Packages): 1-2 hours -- Task 3 (Environment): 2-3 hours -- Task 4 (Keycloak): 3-4 hours -- Task 5 (Documentation): 2-3 hours -- Task 6 (Smoke Tests): 2-3 hours - -### Risk Factors -- Docker configuration complexity -- Keycloak realm import unpredictability -- Package dependency resolution - -## Change Log -| Date | Version | Description | Author | -|------|---------|-------------|--------| -| 2025-01-21 | 1.0 | Created remediation story for Story 1.4 critical gaps | Dev Agent | - -## Dev Agent Record - -### Agent Model Used -_TBD_ - -### Debug Log References -_TBD_ - -### Completion Notes List -_TBD_ - -### File List -_TBD_ - -## QA Results -_TBD_ \ No newline at end of file